1.4 million American workers apply for unemployment benefits, as relief bill negotiations drag on

A person wearing a protective mask walks past a store for lease in San Francisco, Calif., on Dec. 8, 2020.

David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Worsening outlook

Together, initial claims are at their highest point since mid-September.

“[The] rebound signals things aren’t just stagnating, they’re worsening,” Daniel Zhao, an economist at Glassdoor, a job and recruiting site, said.

Nine months into the crisis, the volume of initial claims eclipses any pre-pandemic record.

When stripping out data for the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance program, which was created in March by the CARES Act relief law, claims for state benefits are still higher than all but the worst week of the Great Recession.

‘Resurgent virus’

“Layoffs appear to be rising, consistent with the resurgent virus,” Heidi Shierholz, director of policy at the Economic Policy Institute, a left-leaning think tank, and former Labor Department chief economist, wrote Thursday in an analysis.

The U.S. recorded 3,124 new Covid-19 deaths on Wednesday, the deadliest single-day tally of the pandemic so far, according to a CNBC analysis of Johns Hopkins University data.

States like California have implemented new lockdown measures and stay-at-home orders to contain the outbreak.

Unemployment benefits generally replace half of a worker’s lost wages. However, some workers get much less of a wage replacement due to weekly caps on aid amounts, which vary widely among states. Six states — Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and Tennessee — cap their unemployment benefits at a level below the country’s $7.25 hourly minimum wage.

Roughly 19 million Americans were collecting unemployment benefits at the end of November.

Multiple layoffs

Evidence suggests most new applications for unemployment benefits are coming from workers who have been laid off multiple times during the Covid pandemic.

Such claims accounted for 80% of all initial claims in California during the last week in October, according to a recent analysis published by the California Policy Lab. The U.S. Labor Department doesn’t report such figures for the whole country.

“It’s hard to know if these folks are applying for a second (or even third) time, but it’s very likely,” Eliza Forsythe, an assistant professor and labor economist at the University of Illinois, said of nationwide claims data.

Workers who re-enter the unemployment system essentially pick up where they left off, meaning they have fewer weeks of assistance available.

Repeat claims make it difficult to determine who may soon exhaust benefits, Forsythe said.

While the high level of unemployment claims is concerning, the extent to which Thanksgiving influenced last week’s spike in unclear, she said. Workers who would have otherwise filed during the holiday week may have been pushed to the following week.

“I’d like to see another week of data before feeling comfortable saying that claims are rising,” she said.